10 actors who could make the new Daredevil swing

Contributed by
Dec 14, 2012

If Fox is attempting a movie reboot of Marvel's Man Without Fear, they'll definitely need a star. And, rather than contemplate any further the prospect of Robert Pattinson strapping on the crimson leathers, here are some other, far better options—including one curve ball.

Which of these blokes could bring the most to Matt Murdock, blind attorney-at-law who patrols the New York City night as Daredevil?


Michael Pitt

michael_pitt_large.jpg

His role on HBO's Boardwalk Empire has shown that this former cherub has got the steel of a real actor—steel that could be set to work in Hell's Kitchen.


Ben Foster

ben_foster.jpg

Even though it seems like he buries himself almost to unrecognizablility in movies like 30 Days of Night, 3:10 to Yuma and X-Men: The Last Stand (okay, he was the guy with the wings), his talent finds a way to shine.


James McAvoy

james-mcavoy.jpg

No stranger to comics or American accents, the Wanted and X-Men: First Class veteran can bring both the intelligence and the physicality required to make Daredevil bounce.


Ryan Gosling

ryan_gosling_suit.jpg

Ah, who are we kidding? He'd never do it. Despite the fact that he can simmer like few actors and could really tear into the role—forcing you to buy both the lawyer and the vigilante—the indie darling would never do it. (Or would he?)


Chris Pine

chris_pine.jpg

Sure, he's already got his franchises—Star Trek and a nascent Jack Ryan reboot—but there's a smarmy pluck to Pine that could serve Daredevil well.


Joseph Gordon-Levitt

joseph_gordon_levitt.jpg

Inception and (500) Days of Summer have shown us the varied range of this former child actor, his gritty-suave action chops and his light-on-the-outside comedic timing. That's a perfect blend for Daredevil.


Chris Hemsworth

Chris_Hemsworth.jpg

Maybe he's a hair too big for Matt Murdock, maybe he's already embroiled in the Marvel Universe with Thor. Who cares? He'd be grand.


Michael Trucco

Michael_Trucco.jpg

He's being wasted on basic-cable legal dramas. If you're anything like me, when you first saw him on Battlestar Galactica, you said to yourself, "That dude's a goddamn hero." Maybe this could be his shot.


Cillian Murphy

cillian_murphy.jpg

Is he simply too pretty for the part? Perhaps, but I'd like to think that he could use that to his advantage, selling the dual identities as few could.


Ben Affleck

Ben_Affleck_Town.jpg

No, not to star. Been there, done that. But he'd be a fantastic director, if this whole David Slade thing doesn't work out. Affleck's better behind the camera than he ever was in front of it, and he knows how to film cities from the bottom up. Plus, he's got a passing familiarity with the character.


Who'd we leave out? Who would you want as the new Daredevil?