Wonder Woman first appearance

All Star Comics #8: Wonder Woman debut sells for record sum

Contributed by
Aug 28, 2017

Apparently Wonder Woman’s current popularity isn’t limited to the box office, because William Moulton Marston and H.G. Peter’s original introduction to the character – All Star Comics #8 – just sold for a record $936,223. Not a bad ROI for a comic with a 10-cent price tag on the cover. Granted, that was way back in 1941, so I guess you have to factor in some inflation, but still, not a bad little investment.

The issue contains the first appearance of Wonder Woman as well as her origin story, and if there is such a thing as an ordinary All Star Comic #8, this eBay item certainly isn’t it. With a 9.4 CGC grade, it’s the highest Certified Guaranty Company-graded copy of this issue known, with the closest competition rated at 9.0, which was good enough to earn $411,001 at auction in 2016.   

all star comics #8 wonder woman

According to Bleeding Cool, who spoke with the seller, Darren Adams of Pristine Comics (who also sold that record-setting Action Comics #1 for a cool $3.2 mil), the original collector owned a mom-and-pop grocery store. For about the duration of World War II, Pop collected a core group of superheroes — including Superman, Batman, and Wonder Woman. He used to buy the books, some 400 all told, directly from a magazine distributor, then take them home, “where they remained undisturbed, for over 70-plus years.”

Sensation Comics #1 Wonder Woman

Two other seminal Wonder Woman titles also sold from the collection yesterday. Sensation Comics #1, which came out about two weeks after All Star Comics #8, expounded on Wonder Woman’s origin story and also brought Diana Prince to “Man’s World.” This book, with an astounding 9.6 CGC grade, sold for a record sum of $399,100. And a 9.0-rated “solicitation copy” of Wonder Woman #1 from 1942 pulled in $226,877 (surprisingly, nearly $70,000 less than it sold for back in December).

wonder woman #1

So yeah, it may be time to dust off a few of those classic Wonder Woman comics in the attic and see how much they're worth.

Make Your Inbox Important

Like Comic-Con. Except every week in your inbox.

Sign-up breaker
Sign out: