Warning: If you don't want to know what happened in this episode, don't read this photo recap!
Guilt-ridden over turning Mike in to the cops, Marla arrives at the Sheriff's office looking to talk to him. But Mike ain't there.
206966
Gary's taken Mike to this abandoned house, probably to do some very un-Sheriff-like stuff to him.
206967
Tim and Daphne join Gary as they all begin the illegal interrogation. They want answers about the Iron Hill murders, and they think Mike, who's already confessed to one, has them.
206968
Mike tells them that Eddie was able to use telekinetic powers to mind control the bully Gene, Tim's brother, and have him take a nosedive off a cliff. At the Crow's Nest. So in turn, Mike says that he had to stop his out of control brother, who was under the influence of Candle Cove. Of course, no one buys it.
206969
Meanwhile, back in town, officer Amy intervenes on a group of kids with toy pirate knives stabbing a mannequin underneath some power lines. Ah, suburbia.
206970
At the not-so-safe house, Tim pulls a gun. Tim goes to aim the gun. Gary goes to Tim. Oh, it's a scuffle.
206972
Jessica, Marla and Amy show up at the abandoned house where Gary has taken Mike. It's going to take a lot of couples therapy to heal this wound. Turns out, Jessica and Mike had been exchanging emails (that Gary found!) long before Mike showed up in town. So for Gary, maybe this interrogation is about something more than the murders?
206974
Before, Tim wanted Mike to talk. But now that Amy, Jessica and Marla have arrived at the house, he wants Mike to stop talking. Make up your mind, Tim!
206976
At the hospital, Mike tells Amy that Eddie killed the four kids during the Iron Hill murders under the influence of Candle Cove…and then he disappeared. So this handles the whole "will the cops want to take Mike in for murdering his brother" problem.
206977
Daphne gives Mrs. Booth, the teacher and Marla's friend, the inside scoop on what went down at the abandoned house. Booth lost her only son to the Iron Hill murders...and to Eddie.
206978
Mrs. Booth thanks Daphne by giving her a hook to the throat. "You shouldn't f#$k with Mike Painter," says Mrs. Booth. Well, at least somebody's on Mike's side.
206979
Mrs. Booth has a bunch of young kids over at her house - the same ones Amy caught stabbing the mannequin - to watch Candle Cove and drink hot cocoa. Also, see how they're covered in blood? These same lil rascals murdered Tim as he walked home through the woods and Mrs. Booth helped them hide the body. Nothing weird/illegal/inappropriate about that at all.
206980
And somehow Lily, Mike's daughter, has walked all the way from her home in Westchester, NY to visit him in Iron Hill- Ohio! Hopefully she didn't hitchhike — because THAT'S dangerous.
