The only thing worse than having your place torn apart is finding the culprit sitting in the middle of the mess with a knife. Dwight has found the knife that Wade used to kill a young Haven-ite but he thinks Duke did it.
But when her and William go off to find the Trouble Audrey finds out that William is the culprit. Turns out, the two henchman work for him and he declares that Audrey was HIS in a past life. Audrey blacks out and when she comes to Nathan is there with his ever-ready embrace.